Simonton vs. Milgard Windows Comparison Guide: Pricing, Reviews, and the Real Pros and Cons
Table of Contents
When it comes to building your dream home, remodeling an income-generating ADU, or maximizing the ROI of your next construction project, few choices are as critical as the windows you select.
While there are many custom-sized windows on the market, few brands are as well known as Milgard and Simonton. However, that doesn’t mean that the two manufacturers are created equal. In today’s article, we take a closer look at how Milgard and Simonton stack up — and help you identify which brand produces the best custom-sized windows for your needs.
Milgard vs Simonton Online Scorecards: Pros & Cons of the Popular Window Brands
We offer a more granular breakdown of major categories, like pricing and customer satisfaction, below. However, we wanted to provide a list of the biggest pros and cons right out of the gates — as well as how other online review sites, thought leaders, and homeowners rank Milgard Windows & Doors next to Simonton Windows, Inc.
Simonton Windows: Pros & Cons
Biggest Pro: Wide Availability
The fact that Simonton Windows are widely available across the United States is a main selling point. However, some regions have limited availability, and some series can only be purchased and installed through Home Depot.
Biggest Cons: Poor Online Reviews and Ratings for Customer Service, Durability, and Long-Term Value
Simonton doesn’t hit the mark for homeowners or professional contractors/architects when it comes to customer service, durability, or maintaining their value. The editors at Forbes Home take a deep dive into the brand, including their online reviews, citing that “most reviews on BBB’s website are negative, with customers mainly expressing dissatisfaction with the quality of Simonton’s materials and customer service.”
Overall, Forbes Home editors rank Simonton just 3.4 out of 5 stars (68%).
Milgard Windows: Pros & Cons
Biggest Pros: Incredible Value, Long-term Durability, and Excellent Service
When it comes to generating actual value, Milgard is the clear winner. The company’s commitment to using the best materials, employing excellent craftsmanship, and providing the best service has earned it top reviews from both industry professionals and residential homeowners.
In fact, Forbes Home editors rank Milgard Windows and Doors nearly 20 points higher than Simonton (84% vs. 68%)
Biggest Cons: Regional Availability
Without question, the biggest drawback of the Milgard brand is that it can be difficult to acquire their products outside of the West Coast. Presently, Milgard Windows and Doors are available to customers living in: Arizona, California, Colorado, Nevada, Oregon, and Washington.
Milgard vs Simonton: Windows Pricing, Cost Considerations, and Obtaining Quotes
Challenges with obtaining clear pricing for custom windows
Generally speaking, Milgard often has a lower price point than comparable Simonton models. However, modern windows come with a variety of features, options, and upgrades that can dramatically impact price — even for windows that are within the same window series.
So, it should come as no surprise that one of the most frustrating components of the buying process is obtaining accurate, fast, and hassle-free pricing. In addition to limited online pricing information, most prospective buyers will also encounter one of the following challenges:
Scenario 1: They head to their local hardware store and seek advice from employees who don’t really specialize in custom-size windows — an area where a miscalculation of less than an inch can cost you thousands of dollars and render your windows completely useless.
Scenario 2: They contact an area dealer hoping to obtain a quick quote and are instead greeted by sales reps so pushy that they’ll beat down your door to sell you even a slightly pricier window.
Neither option is ideal, and it’s one of the leading reasons why ConstructionWindows.com built our proprietary custom-sized windows builder. It allows customers to easily build their windows, obtain instant pricing, modify & save projects, and comes packed with a ton of useful and time-saving features.
Simonton vs. Milgard Windows Comparison Guide: Pricing, Reviews, and the Real Pros and Cons
Milgard Windows & Doors Pricing: Instant Quotes
We make obtaining Milgard pricing a snap with our online builder. If you’re unsure of which Milgard Windows series is right for you, we recommend checking out the following product lines:
- Milgard Tuscany Windows V400 Series: The Tuscany Windows V400 Series combines classic beauty with advanced features. These windows are designed with Milgard’s signature vinyl formula for enhanced durability and energy efficiency and are sure to add a touch of elegance to any home.
- Milgard Trinsic Windows V300 Series: Milgard Trinsic Windows offer a contemporary, sleek look, allowing for unobstructed views and ample natural light.
- Milgard Style Line Windows V250 Series: The Style Line V250 Series combines quality and affordability. With their narrow frame design, these windows offer an expanded view and allow more natural light into your home.
- Milgard Ultra Fiberglass Windows C650 Series: For homeowners seeking exceptional durability and performance, Milgard’s Ultra Fiberglass C650 Series is an ideal option. They offer excellent insulation, reducing energy consumption and enhancing home comfort.
- Milgard Aluminum Thermal Break Windows A250 Series: Combining sleek aesthetics with exceptional durability, the Aluminum Thermal Break Windows A250 Series is a top choice for homeowners seeking sleek window designs.
Pro-Tip: While Milgard Windows are exceptionally priced for the value they offer, there are a number of ways customers can save money. For example:
- Depending on the windows’ features, customers might be entitled to various tax credits.
- If customers are replacing outdated windows, they will likely receive significant savings in terms of energy efficiency.
By working with a Certified Milgard Dealer, like ConstructionWindows.com, customers can access deep discounts and promotions offered throughout the year!
Simonton Windows & Doors Pricing
Since Simonton windows & doors can also be heavily customized, your best bet for obtaining pricing information is to contact an area dealer. Alternatively, the company does offer a few products exclusively through Home Depot, and pricing can be obtained through their website for off the shelf product – with zero ability to customize the windows on their website.
Simonton also put together this guide to help prospective customers determine the ballpark pricing of custom-sized window replacements. While it’s unclear how closely the guide’s pricing reflects that of Simonton’s, most replacement pricing ranges from several hundred dollars to as much as $5,500.
Milgard vs Simonton: Professional Ratings, Service Reviews, and Customer Testimonials
From the quality of materials used in construction to the aftercare service the companies provide, we think there is a clear winner for most customers (especially those on the West Coast): Milgard Windows.
However, you don’t need to take our word for it. Milgard crushes the competition when it comes to professional ratings, reviews of the service they provide customers, and users’ own words. Check out a few of the most notable below.
|
Statistic
|
Milgard
|
Simonton
|
|---|---|---|
|
Architectural Digest
|
||
|
Home Depot Rating*
|
||
|
Service Satisfaction
|
NOT featured on site
|
*Home Depot ranking compares “Simonton Double-Hung Windows” to “Milgard Double-Hung Window”, retrieved June 2024 from HomeDepot.com.
Getting the Best Deals on Milgard Windows and Doors
If you’re considering Milgard Windows and Doors for your next construction project, we’d love to help you find the perfect options to fit your needs, whether you’re a contractor looking to delight a hard-to-please customer, a homeowner replacing outdated windows, or a first-time investor who wants to ensure that your ADU commands as much as it can in the market.
To get started, simply contact us today!